SAN FRANCISCO — Shortly before midnight on May 31, a man with two guns walked through the gate of a homeless shelter on Bayshore Boulevard. More than 100 people were staying inside. What the staff did next is now a criminal case.
District Attorney Brooke Jenkins says two employees of the Bayshore Navigation Center helped hide a man accused of shooting a San Francisco police officer. The workers and the nonprofit that ran the shelter tell a different story: that the staff were held at gunpoint, kept their clients safe and got the police there.
On Thursday, Oct. 29, a San Francisco Superior Court judge is scheduled to weigh the evidence and decide whether the case goes to trial. For the Bayview, where the shelter sits and where the shooting happened, the question reaches past two defendants. It goes to what the city expects of the workers it pays to run its shelters when danger walks in the door.
A chase that ended at Jerrold Avenue
The San Francisco Police Department’s account goes like this. At about 10:29 p.m. on May 31, officers tried to stop a car near Mission and First streets driven by a robbery suspect. Mission Local reported that a license-plate alert had tied the car to an armed robbery in the East Bay. The driver fled and crashed near Bayshore Boulevard and Jerrold Avenue.
Police say the driver opened fire and hit an officer several times, and officers fired back. Officer Brittney Taylor was gravely wounded. A passenger in the car, Ariunsanaa Dolgorsuren, was critically injured. ShotSpotter data indicates 19 shots were fired, Mission Local reported. SFPD said in August that the officer had been released from the hospital and was recovering.
Police say the driver, Norris Reed III, 36, ran across the street to the navigation center at 125 Bayshore Blvd. At 12:17 a.m., a staff member called to report him inside the center’s gate. Officers arrested him in the fenced courtyard and took two guns from his waistband, SFPD said. The District Attorney’s Office has charged Reed with attempted murder and other felonies. The charges against him are allegations; he has not been convicted.
What prosecutors say the workers did
In August, police arrested two shelter employees, Oliver Barcenas, 36, and Erika Porter, 45. Prosecutors charged both with being an accessory after the fact and with obstructing and delaying a police officer. Porter faces two more misdemeanor counts of lying to police. She pleaded not guilty in August, Mission Local reported.
Police allege that security video shows Barcenas passing Reed a jacket and a hat through a window, and that Porter told officers she did not know where Reed was while he sat nearby, out of sight. Prosecutors say the clothing was meant to disguise him.
Jenkins called the video “stunning” and said it “shows clear evidence” that the two “made a choice.” Police Chief Derrick Lew focused on the clock. “It took almost an hour and a half for someone to call 911 after this suspect arrived at the navigation center,” Lew said.
What the workers say happened
The shelter was run by Five Keys, a nonprofit. Steve Good, its CEO at the time and now retired, said Reed showed staff two guns and told them not to call the police. Good said he has watched the footage and does not know what the district attorney finds stunning. He called it a hostage situation and called the workers’ actions “nothing short of heroism,” Mission Local reported.
Barcenas’ attorney, Gabriel Navarrete, has said Reed got past courtyard staff who took him for a client. When a worker at a security checkpoint did not recognize him and asked questions, Reed drew his weapons, Navarrete said, according to SFist. The defense says Barcenas and Porter moved shelter guests out of harm’s way while Reed sat in the courtyard. Then a staff member called 911.
The workers say they acted under duress, SFist reported. The question for the judge on Thursday is narrow: whether prosecutors have enough evidence to send the case to a jury.
Why the Bayview is watching
Navigation centers are city-funded shelters run by nonprofit contractors. The people at their front gates are not police officers.
That is the heart of the dispute. Prosecutors point to a delay of more than an hour and a jacket handed through a window. The defense points to two workers with an armed man in the courtyard and a building full of vulnerable people behind them.
An officer nearly died that night. A passenger was critically hurt. No one disputes that. What a judge decides Thursday will tell shelter workers across San Francisco what the city believes they owe in a moment like that one.
The preliminary hearing for Oliver Barcenas and Erika Porter is scheduled for Thursday, Oct. 29, in San Francisco Superior Court before Judge Dawn Payne.
This story draws on reporting by Mission Local and SFist and on statements from the San Francisco Police Department.
Photo: San Francisco’s Hall of Justice at 850 Bryant St. Photo via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.
Support 82 years of Black Bay Area journalism. Our stories are free to read. A $20-a-year subscription keeps them coming.









