DUBLIN — Antoine Dewhitt died in May. Five months later, the Alameda County Sheriff’s Office says it left him out of its count.
Dewhitt, 40, of Oakland, suffered a medical emergency at Santa Rita Jail in mid-April, less than a day after he was booked on a probation violation. He was taken to a hospital, where the jail formally released him from custody. He died May 9, about three weeks later. His death certificate lists an excessive amount of fentanyl, KTVU reported Tuesday.
His death was never announced. Sheriff’s Sgt. Roberto Morales told KTVU that the office left it out of its in-custody death count because of an oversight. After hearing from Dewhitt’s sister, the office will now include him. That makes five in-custody deaths at Santa Rita this year. KTVU’s data and reporting put the total at 80 since 2014.
Santa Rita is Alameda County’s jail, and this year it has been Oakland’s grief. Four of the five people whose deaths there have been reported this year were from Oakland. When a death goes uncounted, it is Oakland families who are left asking what happened.
A sister’s questions
It was Dewhitt’s sister, Antoinette Staples, who brought his case forward. She contacted the sheriff’s office after a 36-year-old Oakland woman held at the jail died in October, and wondered why her brother’s death had never been made public.
“I have so many questions,” Staples said.
One of them: Dewhitt went to the hospital twice on the day of his emergency, and Staples said she does not know why he was sent back to the jail after the first trip.
Staples said her brother had a hard life. He came home from a prison term in 2023, and she said he was “doing the best I had ever seen him.” The grandmother who raised him died about a month after his release. He is survived by his daughter, Akayla Dewhitt; his girlfriend, Latida Daniels, who described him as friendly, loving and funny; and his sisters, Staples and Karess Reed. Staples said she hopes to hold a memorial soon.
Five deaths, and a pattern at the hospital door
News reports this year have described these other deaths of people held at the jail. Several ran through a hospital.
- Kenyonna Farr, 37, of Oakland, was found unresponsive in a holding cell on the morning of a court date in March. She was taken to a hospital, cleared to return to the jail, and was found unresponsive again the next morning. She died about 30 minutes later. The coroner ruled she died of cardiomyopathy related to obesity, KTVU reported.
- Brandon Watson, 37, of San Francisco, was found unresponsive in a dormitory housing unit in early June after he did not report for breakfast, SFist reported.
- Jeffrey McMaster, 44, of Oakland, who was being held on a murder charge, collapsed in the restroom of the jail’s outpatient facility in June. He had been treated at a hospital after a seizure in his cell days earlier, SFist reported.
- Jessica Watson, 36, of Oakland, was booked Oct. 10 after an arrest by Hayward police on outstanding warrants. Deputies found her unresponsive in her cell Oct. 13 with what appeared to be a ligature around her neck. She was taken to a hospital, released on her own recognizance the next day, and pronounced dead Oct. 22, CBS News Bay Area reported. A forensic pathologist will determine the cause of death.
In at least two of this year’s deaths, Dewhitt’s and Jessica Watson’s, the person was released from custody while in the hospital. Farr was sent from the hospital back to her cell.
A jail already under a court order
Santa Rita has been under a federal consent decree since February 2022, the result of a class action, Babu v. County of Alameda, brought on behalf of people held there. The decree requires the county to improve mental health staffing and treatment, screen people for suicide risk when they arrive, and sharply limit the use of safety cells, according to class counsel. Court-approved experts and the plaintiffs’ lawyers monitor compliance through regular tours of the jail.
In Jessica Watson’s case, the sheriff’s office said the Alameda County District Attorney’s Office was notified and the death will be reported to the California Attorney General’s Office. Dewhitt’s death was not counted until his sister asked.
A death in custody is supposed to be the one number a jail never gets wrong. In Dublin this year, it took a grieving sister to correct it.
Families with questions about a loved one held at Santa Rita Jail can contact the Alameda County Sheriff’s Office. If you or someone you know is struggling, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.
This report draws on KTVU, CBS News Bay Area, SFist and court records summarized by class counsel in Babu v. County of Alameda.
Support 82 years of Black Bay Area journalism. Our stories are free to read. A $20-a-year subscription keeps them coming.









