SAN FRANCISCO — You know the scene. A long row of self-checkout machines and one worker to watch them all.

Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman wants to change the math. He has introduced a measure that would require grocery and retail stores to assign one employee for every three self-checkout stations. A second part would limit self-checkout to 15 items or fewer.

The case for it

Supporters give three reasons: better service, less theft and jobs. They say one worker watching a long row of machines is too much to ask. They point to a federal projection that cashier jobs will fall 6 percent nationally over the next decade. That is about 200,000 jobs.

The case against it

The California Grocers Association says the rule could push grocery prices up or lead stores to pull the machines out. Opponents say 10 stores in Long Beach removed self-checkout after that city passed its own rule in 2025.

The San Francisco Chamber of Commerce questions whether the measure is needed. It says theft at self-checkout has gone down, and that store workers are often told not to confront people suspected of shoplifting anyway.

What happens next

No hearing date has been announced. If the measure passes, the city’s Office of Labor Standards Enforcement and the City Attorney’s Office would enforce it.

Until then, the machines stay the way they are.

Share this storyFacebookXEmail

Support 82 years of Black Bay Area journalism. Our stories are free to read. A $20-a-year subscription keeps them coming.