OAKLAND — At about 8:30 p.m. last Wednesday, the screens in Oakland’s police dispatch center froze. Then the phones went dead. Then the internet.

For roughly the next 36 hours, a call to 911 from anywhere in Oakland, West Oakland to deep East Oakland, did not reach the Oakland Police Department’s own dispatchers. It went to the Alameda County Sheriff’s Office instead.

Police and AT&T said copper and fiber optic lines had been cut. The city said phone service to all its systems was back by about 8:30 a.m. Friday, after city and AT&T crews worked through the night. No one has been arrested.

Priority One only

Oakland police dispatchers moved to the sheriff’s dispatch center and to the Oakland Fire Department’s and kept working Oakland calls from there. With limited room, police responded only to Priority One calls, the most urgent kind, KTVU reported.

Sheriff’s Sgt. Roberto Morales said no delays were reported because of the disruption. The city’s OAK311 line went down too, and officials asked residents to send reports by email until it came back.

Police Chief James Beere called the level of disruption “not normal” at a news conference Thursday. “This is a perfect example of theft leading to something far more severe and serious,” he said.

Two fallback plans, both compromised

Oakland had a plan for this. It had two. Neither held.

“Unfortunately both of the initial fallback plans were compromised,” Beere said, ABC7 reported. He did not describe what those plans were. He said that in almost 30 years he had never seen optic lines go out and phones disconnect in a way that reached the fire department’s system.

AT&T blamed “theft and vandalism.” Police are investigating the cuts as a possible criminal act. The city has not said where the lines were cut, how many calls were rerouted or why the backups failed. The police and fire chiefs are discussing technology that doesn’t depend on cables, KTVU reported.

Mark Chase, a 911 systems expert, told ABC7 the problem is bigger than one city. “Currently the 911 technology that is in use is 911 era technology,” he said. Copper wiring, he said, “is reliable but it is aging and subject to failure.”

Oakland wasn’t alone that week. In the South Bay, Morgan Hill and Gilroy police lost their non-emergency lines after copper cables were cut. Their 911 lines stayed up.

The council wants answers

Councilmember Charlene Wang, who chairs the council’s Public Safety Committee, said many of her constituents rely on the non-emergency line. “We really need to ensure that the security of our systems are in place,” she said. “I’m glad we have a backup plan but we need to make sure this isn’t happening.”

The city thanked the sheriff’s office and said it “will continue to work with AT&T to harden critical infrastructure and strengthen backup systems.”

A good-news week, interrupted

The outage landed in the same week Beere told the Oakland Chamber of Commerce that the city’s homicides and shootings had fallen to historic lows. “This is the lowest amount of homicides and shootings that we’ve seen since the ’60s,” he said, crediting license plate readers, the return of the Ceasefire strategy and closer work with the district attorney’s office.

Those gains depend on people being able to reach help. For a day and a half, the first link in that chain ran through somebody else’s building, on borrowed desks, answering only the worst calls.

It worked this time, as far as anyone has said. The questions are about next time: who cut the lines, why both backups failed and what the city will build so that a pair of wire cutters can’t do this again.

Get involved: Oakland police are asking anyone who sees someone cutting or removing cable to report it. In an emergency, call 911.

This report draws on KTVU, ABC7, CBS News Bay Area and the Oakland Report.

Photo: Oakland City Hall. Photo by Almonroth via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Share this storyFacebookXEmail

Support 82 years of Black Bay Area journalism. Our stories are free to read. A $20-a-year subscription keeps them coming.